Palomino Blackwing Wooden Pencil – 602 Model

27 01 2012


I did not know the original Palomino Blackwing pencil, but I could not miss the reverential and longing mentions of it around office supply circles, and I certainly couldn’t help noticing the adorational fanfare showered at its return, for the graphite savior of all that is wood-cased walks writes among us again. Not that I could afford to bask in its presence—$20 ($19.95, if you want to be nitpickingly precise) is a bit steep of an entry price in my books, and twelve pencils is a lot to commit to, considering I don’t even know if I’ll like the thing. Luckily, Brad at JetPens kindly offered to let me sample a brand-new spare Blackwing 602 he had lying around, thus saving me from an eternity of wandering, lonely, in a Blackwingless world.

The prodigal wood-case wonder

Fairly normal-looking pencil body on one end, bafflingly peculiar paintbrush-like eraser on the other end. We’ll break it down one piece at a time, starting with the body.

Branding CAN be beautiful!

One side is stamped with the brand name and model.

...than what, a regular pencil? This I can neither confirm nor deny.

And the other side is stamped with a slogan/promise. Notice on both that the gold lettering actually lines up with the stamping, unlike so many ten cent pencils of my youth. The extra money you’re paying is going toward making a higher quality product (rather than toward, say, Palomino’s champagne and cigar fund). And can we take a second to admire this paint job?

More class than an entire K-12 educational system

I didn’t know it was possible for something to be sparkly AND classy, but somehow they’ve managed it. This is some premium paint with a polished shine. And I believe that Office Supply Geek was right—it looks like there are two coats of paint on this pencil.

See the line of black underneath the silver? Two coats.

Now, I haven’t written with wooden pencils since probably about the time that Beanie Babies were popular and the Backstreet Boys were relevant. Pencils smudge, wooden pencils maliciously so—or so it always seemed to me. Having the side of your hand be totally silver after writing an essay is not as cool as you might think. So how does our Palomino Blackwing 602 stack up? Pretty well, I am surprised to admit, in spite of my pencil prejudice. In writing up this review by hand (with the Palomino Blackwing, of course), I’ve done almost 3 pages in a 6.5″ x 8.25″ Clairefontaine notebook, and though there is noticeable silvering on my hand, it’s not as much as I’d expect for lead this dark. And the lead itself is silky-smooth. None of the scratchiness you get from cheap leads (which, I presume, are riddled with little airholes which leave small sharp surfaces throughout the lead….but I could be making that up).

Not actually a paintbrush...unless you want to paint graphite OFF some paper

Saved the best for last—this absolutely odd eraser, which turns out to be an entire miniature block eraser. Just pull on those little curlicues, and out comes the eraser. You can extend it as it runs down, and replace it if it runs out.

This kind of extendability/replaceability is typically only seen on the uselessly tiny little crumbs they dare to call erasers and send standard on the end of most mechanical pencils, protected beneath an easy-to-lose little plastic cap

Performance of the eraser is not 100% what I’d like—you can still see the ghost of what was written, especially if I wrote with a sharp edge or pressure. The plasticky, polymer erasers I have do a better job of erasing. It’d be nice if Palomino offered a polymer refill, but I might just grab an X-Acto knife and make one of my own.

This is unwieldy. You'll probably break the eraser. I do not recommend using your eraser like this

As I mentioned in the written sample, even a pencil as nice as this one isn’t going to convince me to start back at being a pencil writer. And as sharp and snazzy as this number looks, it’s not invincible—I’ve already got some dings in the wood. But I like it for drawing; with lead this smooth, nice, and dark, it makes a great sketch pencil. Having to carry a sharpener around is a bit inconvenient, but not the end of the world.

If you like writing with pencils, you’ll probably love this pencil. If you like sketching, this is a good drawing pencil with a high capacity on-board eraser. If you’re not a pencil person, or just don’t care for wooden pencils, then save your $20. The cost is a little prohibitive, but the Palomino Blackwing 602 is a high quality pencil.

Thanks again to Brad for the sample!

Palomino Blackwing Wooden Pencil – 602 Model – Pack of 12 at JetPens



9 responses

28 01 2012

Outstanding review No Pen! Wry, honest, self-revealing, and loved the Pencil Jesus imagery, which is just right. The Palomino Blackwing is the Risen Son of the Original (God Almighty) Eberhard-Faber Blackwing 602, the instrument of Creation of Sondheim and Steinbeck, the Graphite Deliverer for whom the Evangelists of The Church Of The One True Woodcase Pencil zealously do battle on the fields of ebay, laying waste their Benjamins, the finest C-notes of their Quantitative Easing. It’s Holy Writ(e), kid. The Eberhard-Faber Blackwing 602 shalt (Shalt!, I say) be saved from Infidels like you and me lest we despoil their Immaculation in our hackery.

Sorry No Pen, I ran away with myself while meaning absolutely no disrepect to your fine analysis of a first-rate pencil. It’s the commodity fetishest inside of me at war with my Dixon Ticonderoga budget. That’s a deadly sin, innit?

9 02 2012
No Pen Intended

:D love it. Honestly I prefer something not so astronomical (the Ohto Comfort Sharp works fantastically and is only $3.30…man I really need to review that one), but if someone else is picking up the tab, then sure, I’ll take a whole box of Palominos!

30 01 2012
Monday Morning Review Round-up « European Paper Company

[…] No Pen Intended: Parker Reflex Fountain Pen & Palomino Blackwing Wooden Pencil – 602 Model […]

6 02 2012
Monday Grab Bag of Links … | The Pretense of Knowledge

[…] restores fountain pens Ink Nouveau: Jamie Grossman’s Noodler’s UV Torture Test Palomino Blackwing Wooden Pencil – 602 Model Glass pens. – Leigh Reyes. My Life As a Verb Ink Links – The Pen Addict Visconti Homo […]

26 04 2012
Monday Morning Review Round-up | The European Paper Company

[…] No Pen Intended: Parker Reflex Fountain Pen & Palomino Blackwing Wooden Pencil – 602 Model […]

26 07 2012
Ohto Pieni Wooden Body Mini Needle-Point Ballpoint Pen – 0.5 mm – Yellow Body « No Pen Intended

[…] I started using the Palomino Blackwing and now the Ohto Pieni, I had forgotten how sensitive wood is. It picks up dings and scratches like […]

4 05 2013
Review of Palomino Blackwing 602. » PENCIL REVOLUTION

[…] from other sites, in alphabetical order (certainly not a complete list): Boing Boing Lexikaliker No Pen Intended Office Supply Geek Pen Addict Pencil Reviewer Planet Millie Recording Thoughts Stationery Traffic […]

3 08 2013
Ink Drop Soup: Category Killers | No Pen Intended

[…] seized my heart. Gel pens, rollerball pens, felt-tip pens, hardcase wooden pencils (though the Palomino Blackwing is pretty strong), lead holders (though I have a soft spot for the Ohto Comfort Sharp), […]

28 03 2017
Palomino Blackwing Slate | No Pen Intended

[…] really stand out feature is that elastic holster on the spine. It comes loaded with the fantastic Palomino Blackwing 602 pencil, but what else can fit on there? Any pen or pencil of comparable thickness of course, but pushing […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: